Copycat
1995 · TMDB 6.5/10 · 1,319 votes
An agoraphobic psychologist and a female detective must work together to take down a serial killer who copies serial killers from the past. This title fits the list's theme and selection thresholds.
Curated by SceneIt · United States
Mystery Movies
Discover popular and highly rated mystery movies. This page focuses on useful, popular choices for viewers in the United States.
Updated 2026-08-03 · Ratings from TMDB
How we chose these titles
Eligible titles are ranked using TMDB popularity, audience rating, and vote count. Streaming availability and ratings can change over time.
Scooby-Doo on Zombie Island
1998 · TMDB 7.7/10 · 864 votes
After going their separate ways, Scooby-Doo, Shaggy, Velma, Daphne, and Fred reunite to investigate the ghost of Moonscar the pirate on a haunted bayou island, but it turns out the swashbuckler's spirit isn't the only creepy character on the island. This title fits the list's theme and selection thresholds.
Sherlock: The Abominable Bride
2016 · TMDB 7.8/10 · 2,363 votes
Sherlock Holmes and Dr. This title fits the list's theme and selection thresholds.
Sommersby
1993 · TMDB 6.4/10 · 431 votes
Set in the South just after the US Civil War, Laurel Sommersby is just managing to work the farm without her husband, believed killed in battle. This title fits the list's theme and selection thresholds.
State of Play
2009 · TMDB 6.8/10 · 2,175 votes
When a congressional aide is killed, a Washington, D.C. This title fits the list's theme and selection thresholds.
Prom Night
2008 · TMDB 5.1/10 · 800 votes
Donna's senior prom is supposed to be the best night of her life, though a sadistic killer from her past has different plans for her and her friends. This title fits the list's theme and selection thresholds.
Paycheck
2003 · TMDB 6.2/10 · 2,068 votes
Michael Jennings is a genius who's hired – and paid handsomely – by high-tech firms to work on highly sensitive projects, after which his short-term memory is erased so he's incapable of breaching security. This title fits the list's theme and selection thresholds.
Red Riding Hood
2011 · TMDB 6.0/10 · 3,334 votes
Valerie is in love with a brooding outsider, Peter, but her parents have arranged for her to marry another man. This title fits the list's theme and selection thresholds.
Fantasy Island
2020 · TMDB 5.8/10 · 2,658 votes
A group of contest winners arrive at an island hotel to live out their dreams, only to find themselves trapped in nightmare scenarios. This title fits the list's theme and selection thresholds.
The Player
1992 · TMDB 7.2/10 · 964 votes
A Hollywood studio executive is being sent death threats by a writer whose script he rejected - but which one? This title fits the list's theme and selection thresholds.
Serenity
2019 · TMDB 5.5/10 · 1,641 votes
The quiet life of Baker Dill, a fishing boat captain who lives on the isolated Plymouth Island, where he spends his days obsessed with capturing an elusive tuna while fighting his personal demons, is interrupted when someone from his past comes to him searching for help. This title fits the list's theme and selection thresholds.
Slender Man
2018 · TMDB 4.3/10 · 2,178 votes
In a small town in Massachusetts, four high school girls perform a ritual in an attempt to debunk the lore of Slender Man. This title fits the list's theme and selection thresholds.
Inheritance
2020 · TMDB 6.3/10 · 745 votes
The patriarch of a wealthy and powerful family suddenly passes away, leaving his wife and daughter with a shocking secret inheritance that threatens to unravel and destroy their lives. This title fits the list's theme and selection thresholds.
The Crazies
2010 · TMDB 6.3/10 · 2,324 votes
Four friends find themselves trapped in their small hometown after they discover their friends and neighbors going quickly and horrifically insane. This title fits the list's theme and selection thresholds.
Inland Empire
2006 · TMDB 7.0/10 · 1,276 votes
When actress Nikki Grace gets the lead role in a cursed film, her world becomes more and more surreal, blending realities and ideas of infidelity, reincarnation, and supernatural forces. This title fits the list's theme and selection thresholds.
The Girl in the Fog
2017 · TMDB 6.8/10 · 1,087 votes
A gripping and chilling thriller that brings us to a hazy mountain village where an enigmatic detective is investigating the sudden disappearance of fifteen-year-old girl. This title fits the list's theme and selection thresholds.
Blow Out
1981 · TMDB 7.4/10 · 1,705 votes
While recording sound effects for a slasher flick, Jack Terry stumbles upon a real-life horror: a car careening off a bridge and into a river. This title fits the list's theme and selection thresholds.
Deep Red
1975 · TMDB 7.7/10 · 1,609 votes
An English pianist living in Rome witnesses the brutal murder of his psychic neighbor. This title fits the list's theme and selection thresholds.
Pandorum
2009 · TMDB 6.6/10 · 2,710 votes
Two crew members wake up on an abandoned spacecraft with no idea who they are, how long they've been asleep, or what their mission is. This title fits the list's theme and selection thresholds.
The Number 23
2007 · TMDB 6.4/10 · 3,567 votes
Animal control officer Walter Sparrow becomes obsessed with a novel that he believes was written about him, as more and more similarities between himself and his literary alter ego seem to arise. This title fits the list's theme and selection thresholds.