Class of '09
2023 · TMDB 7.1/10 · 117 votes
Set in three distinct points in time, follow a class of FBI agents who grapple with immense changes as the U.S. This title fits the list's theme and selection thresholds.
Curated by SceneIt · United States
Mystery TV Shows
Discover popular and highly rated mystery TV shows. This page focuses on useful, popular choices for viewers in the United States.
Updated 2026-08-04 · Ratings from TMDB
How we chose these titles
Eligible titles are ranked using TMDB popularity, audience rating, and vote count. Streaming availability and ratings can change over time.
Beyond Evil
2021 · TMDB 8.5/10 · 189 votes
As a killing resembling a cold case resurfaces in a small town, the chase for the truth falls on two policemen who each harbor secrets of their own. This title fits the list's theme and selection thresholds.
Pretty Little Liars: Original Sin
2022 · TMDB 7.8/10 · 257 votes
Twenty years ago, a series of tragic events almost ripped the blue-collar town of Millwood apart. This title fits the list's theme and selection thresholds.
Signal
2016 · TMDB 8.2/10 · 194 votes
Detectives from the present and a detective from the past communicate via walkie-talkie to solve a long-time unsolved case. This title fits the list's theme and selection thresholds.
Monsterland
2020 · TMDB 6.5/10 · 102 votes
In this fantasy anthology series, encounters with mermaids, fallen angels and other strange beasts drive broken people to desperate acts in an attempt to repair their lives, ultimately showing there is a thin line between man and beast. This title fits the list's theme and selection thresholds.
Stay Close
2021 · TMDB 7.0/10 · 289 votes
When Carlton Flynn vanishes 17 years to the night after Stewart Green did, it sets off a chain reaction in the lives of people connected to both men. This title fits the list's theme and selection thresholds.
The Changeling
2023 · TMDB 6.4/10 · 112 votes
Apollo and Emma's love story is a fairy tale—until Emma mysteriously vanishes. This title fits the list's theme and selection thresholds.
High-Rise Invasion
2021 · TMDB 8.2/10 · 752 votes
High-school girl Yuri suddenly finds herself on the rooftop of a high-rise building. This title fits the list's theme and selection thresholds.
Junji Ito Collection
2018 · TMDB 8.0/10 · 281 votes
A collection of animated horror stories based on the works of Japanese artist Junji Ito. This title fits the list's theme and selection thresholds.
A Murder at the End of the World
2023 · TMDB 6.9/10 · 288 votes
Gen Z amateur sleuth and tech-savvy hacker Darby Hart and eight other guests are invited by a reclusive billionaire to participate in a retreat at a remote location. This title fits the list's theme and selection thresholds.
The Marked Heart
2022 · TMDB 7.7/10 · 290 votes
A man hell-bent on exacting revenge on the organ trafficking organization that murdered his wife becomes involved with the woman who received her heart. This title fits the list's theme and selection thresholds.
The Tailor
2023 · TMDB 7.3/10 · 104 votes
A famous tailor begins to sew a wedding dress for his best friend’s fiancée – but all three have dark secrets that will soon upend their lives. This title fits the list's theme and selection thresholds.
Spawn
1997 · TMDB 8.0/10 · 300 votes
After being betrayed and murdered by his employer, a government assassin is resurrected as a Hellspawn and is forced to act as the reluctant leader of Hell's army. This title fits the list's theme and selection thresholds.
PIECES OF HER
2022 · TMDB 6.5/10 · 214 votes
A woman pieces together her mother's dark past after a violent attack in their small town brings hidden threats and deadly secrets to light. This title fits the list's theme and selection thresholds.
Psychoville
2009 · TMDB 6.9/10 · 101 votes
Five strangers receive blackmail notes from an anonymous source, leading them on a dark and surreal journey as their lives unravel, featuring bizarre characters like a man-child, a one-handed clown, and a blind millionaire. This title fits the list's theme and selection thresholds.
Magical Girl Site
2018 · TMDB 8.2/10 · 188 votes
Aya Asagiri is a middle school girl who has problems both at school with bullying and at home from physical abuse by her brother. This title fits the list's theme and selection thresholds.
Harper's Island
2009 · TMDB 6.9/10 · 270 votes
A group of family and friends travels to a secluded island for a destination wedding. This title fits the list's theme and selection thresholds.
Vienna Blood
2019 · TMDB 7.4/10 · 110 votes
Max Liebermann, a student of Sigmund Freud, helps Detective Rheinhardt in the investigation of a series of disturbing murders around the grand cafes and opera houses of 1900s Vienna. This title fits the list's theme and selection thresholds.
Are You Afraid of the Dark?
2019 · TMDB 7.6/10 · 256 votes
Each season of this horror anthology series follows a different group of kids, members of the Midnight Society, as they discover terrifying curses and creatures. This title fits the list's theme and selection thresholds.
Wolfblood
2012 · TMDB 8.0/10 · 254 votes
Being a teenager is hard enough. This title fits the list's theme and selection thresholds.